Yoshi-1up said:

I chose the hat. It was VERY hard to choose though. I'm a collector so having digital things don't count that much to me. But I really wish I could fight against the doc.

GQ said:

I would choose the hat. I have wanted a mario hat ever since I was a kid.

insultman911 said:

I hate decisions.

Monkeylemur said:

Doc Louis's punch out.

Jettwinlock said:

I think it's just cool they did something like this.

GQ said:

How much stuff does it take to register to get platinum?

ewolf35 said:

I wish there was a way to get both.

YoshLee said:

I have a Luigi hat but I could use a Mario one so I'd choose the hat. I have punch out already and don't think one more charry to fight would make a difference.

1

Nova said:

I was so close to getting platinum. So very close.

gamer guru said:

Ooooh! We buy about 10-15 games and all we get is a calendar! Yes, I'm gold status. It's never enough.

Mischief Shadow said:

The hat for sure.

Nintendoof said:

At least we get something, this was tough for me. But I guess I'm going with the hat.

Snubble said:

Isn't that hat just like the sofa cushion wiisworld posted a while back or an actual hat?

Southpawms20 said:

Man I figured it would be something crappy, but they're both so cool. Luckily I have two club Nintendo accounts and they're both platinum so I get both.